Panera Shortbread Cookies Recipe

Panera Shortbread Cookies Recipe

Panera Shortbread Cookies Recipe is a very traditional recipe and is all time favorite of many. It can be tried on the Christmas or any time of the year. The Panera Short Bread Cookies recipe requires very few ingredients, and easy to prepare without much effort.

Actually, this type of cookie sounds very Christmassy as it’s decorated with colored frosting and cut into many traditional shapes.

How to Make Panera Frosted Cookies?

Panera Sugar Cookie Recipe or Panera Christmas cookie is a similar kind of cookie making process. They can be rolled flat and baked into decorative tasty and buttery cookies.

These classic recipes need lots of passion in cutting it into attractive shapes. It’s fun to do it on holiday season when the whole family is at home. 

Do you have all your cookie cutters out? If not then keep them ready as you need to cut your cookies into preferred shapes and design! Let’s find the ingredients in the kitchen pantry and start making mitten cookie Panera as a challenge.

Ingredients that You Need to Make Panera Frosted Cookies Are:

1 Cup Butter, Real One at Room Temperature

2 Cup Cake Flour

3/4 Cup Confectioners’ Sugar

1/2 Tea Spoon Baking Powder

1 Tea Spoon Vanilla Essence

1 Pinch of Salt

Preparing Frosting for Panera Sugar Cookie Recipe:

1 Cup Sifted Powdered Sugar

¼ Teaspoon Vanilla

1 Tablespoon Milk or Orange Juice

Method of preparing Home Made Panera Frosted Cookies Step by Step:

Step 1:

Preheat the oven at 325 degree F.

Step 2: 

Add all ingredients in a big bowl. Mix the ingredients and knead by hands. Knead to a light dough. Keep the dough inside the fridge that it gets a little harder and easier to cut into shapes.

Step 3:

Line up cookie sheets on a cookie tray. Grease the tray as the cookie sheet sticks onto the tray and never moves. Keep it ready for later use.

Step 4:

Flatten the dough to ¼ inch of chunkiness. Use a sharp knife to make rectangular cookie lines to give it a genuine short bread appearance. 

Step 5:

Insert the cookie tray in the oven. Keep it in the middle position. Bake for 15 minutes. Check the cookies. If they are golden brown then take them out. Don’t overdo the baking.

Cut into square pieces when it cools down properly. Enjoy with your coffee or tea!

Making Frosting:

Take a mixing bowl and mix all ingredients, keep a little milk separated for better balancing strategy. Add the liquid you kept separated. Be careful to mix the milk gradually.

Mix until it reaches to a proper drizzling consistency. Decorate the cookies with the sugar frosting from outside to inside. Also, you can design in any pattern of your choice.

How to Make Panera Bread Tulip Cookie:

Making Panera Bread Tulip Cookie can be very creative curving tulips, mitten, snowman, elks or even a Christmas tree out of the short bread cookie dough. Let’s see what ingredients we need to make this Panera Christmas Cookies. 

Panera Bread Tulip Cookie Ingredients are Given Below:

Ingredients for Tulip Cookie:

1 Cup Real Butter, Smashed Soft

1-1/2 Cups Sugar

3 Eggs Large

2 Teaspoons Fresh Lemon Zest

1/2 Teaspoon Vanilla

3-1/2 Cups Flour

1 Teaspoon Baking Powder

Sticks for Craft Works

For Frosting:

1 Cup Butter, Smashed Soft

6/ 7 Cups Powdered Sugar

6 Tablespoons Milk, Full Cream

1 Teaspoon Lemon Essence

1 Teaspoon Vanilla Flavor

Food Coloring of Your Choice (Mostly Lighter Shades)

2 Table Spoon Rainbow Sprinkles

Method of Preparing Panera bread tulip cookie Step by Step:

Step 1:

Take a big mixing bowl. With an electric beater blend butter and sugar from medium to high. Bring to a creamy texture. Pour egg, one at a time. Beat well after each time you add eggs.

Put lemon zest and vanilla flavor in the mixture. Now, mix in flour and baking powder. It will turn into soft greasy dough.

Wrap the bowl tightly. Put inside the fridge for minimum one hour. It will be more manageable after refrigeration.

Step 2:

Flatten it to 1/4inch dough. Do it on a lightly floured surface. Shape it like a tulip with a cookie cutter or a sharp knife.

Take a cookie sheet lined wide tray. Set two cookie heads on the sheet. Decorate as tulips and make several tulips over craft sticks.

Step 3:

Preheat the oven at 350 degree F. Now bake those tulips in the oven for 7 to 9 minutes. Check if the edges are coming off and turning slightly brown.

Tae couple of more minutes if requires. Also, don’t bake longer tan needed. Remove from the oven. Cool on a cooling rack.

For Frosting:

Mix all the ingredients in a big bowl. Beat into a fluffy cream. Portion the frosting into three separate bowls for different colorings. With a tooth pick take pinch of color and blend well.

Beat again to make an even garnish as you prefer. Sprinkle the multicolored sprinkles over the tulips. Set them as flowers on the plants or as you desire.


The traditional taste of buttery Panera Sugar Cookies is in every child’s memory in the US and it’s served in a basket as made in a bulk. Also, cookie baking, cutting and decoration are enjoyed as a fun family event on that time. Let’s try Panera Sugar Cookie recipe at home and relish the taste and sweet family moment altogether.

You May Also Like:

Subway Sugar Cookies Recipe

Mrs Fields Sugar Cookie Recipes

Wanna avoid...

Burning your Ruth's Chris Chicken?

Too much garlic in your Garlic Butter Shrimp?

Drying out your Ribeye Roast?​