Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Review

Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Review

If you are fond of ice creams, you probably are not new to equipment that is used for making them including the commercial options. This article, Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Review, compares the same brand of ice cream makers made differently with differing features and capacities.

While some are wooden, some are plastic and you need to make your own judgment with the information that you have.

Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Review

What Makes Nostalgia Brand Ice Cream Makers Special?

One thing about the Nostalgia brand is that it comes with different types of ice cream makers with different capacities and you can choose any capacity that you want from the same brand. 

In addition to that, Nostalgia brand comes with ice cream makers made from different materials including real wood and plastic materials. In this case, you have the option to choose your preferred option without stress. 

The other thing with this awesome brand is the different designs and capabilities that make them versatile for use in making ice creams, sorbet, and frozen yogurt, and more. That means with this brand, you have a variety of options to make.

Top 5 Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker

[amazon table=”2415″]

Nostalgia Bucket Ice Cream Maker

[amazon fields=”B004ZEMSFW” value=”thumb” image_size=”large” image_align=”center” ]

With this ice cream maker, you can make up to 4-quarts of ice cream in a matter of minutes. Nostalgia Bucket Ice Cream Maker is also versatile and useful for making gelato and frozen yoghurt and is made from read wood material. It is the best on the market as per the ratings and reviews from the users. 

Electric motor

This special product comes with a powerful motor that is electric and is, therefore, a fully electric machine that needs no manual effort. The motor also features a motor lock and that is useful in keeping the motor in place when in operation. 


One of the concerns before buying any product of this sort is to check on cleaning. After using the ice cream maker, you need to ensure that it is cleaned. Nostalgia Bucket Ice Cream Maker is one of the easiest when it comes to cleaning.


Carry handle for easy transportation

Versatile and can also make yoghurt and gelato

Compatible with all the Nostalgia ice cream kits

Good capacity for commercial and home ice cream making

Easy to clean and wipe messes

See-through lid offers a view of the inside flavor


Not suitable for some countries that need to use voltage converters

Expert opinion: Nostalgia Bucket Ice Cream Maker is good for making ice cream for the family. I would recommend it you are looking for one that is easy to use and to clean.

[amazon fields=”B004ZEMSFW” button_text=”Buy on Amazon” value=”button”]

Nostalgia Double Flavor Ice Cream Maker

[amazon fields=”B01H1LHT4A” value=”thumb” image_size=”large” image_align=”center” ]

Nostalgia Double Flavor Ice Cream Maker comes with two 2 quarts canisters each and that makes a total of 4 quarts capacity. Just like the previous one above, this one is also suitable for family use but the advantage over the first one is that you can make different flavors at the same time. 


This Nostalgia Double Flavor Ice Cream Maker is compatible with other Nostalgia ice cream kits including and thus great for making different flavors that include vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate among other flavors. 

Powerful motor 

On efficiency, Nostalgia Double Flavor Ice Cream Maker features electric motors that do all the churning, and also a motor lock that works to keep the motor in place when in operation.


Suitable for making different ice cream flavors

Large enough to suit family use

Powerful electric motor for efficient churning

Faster than other similar models

Easy to clean and to use


The motor can get hot if it runs for long

Expert opinion: The good thing with Nostalgia Double Flavor Ice Cream Maker is that it works faster than most other similar models. It is also good for making different flavors of ice cream at home.

[amazon fields=”B01H1LHT4A” button_text=”Buy on Amazon” value=”button”]

Nostalgia Blue Ice Cream Maker

[amazon fields=”B07VVDTSQR” value=”thumb” image_size=”large” image_align=”center” ]

Nostalgia Blue Ice Cream Maker is a plastic bucket that you can wipe clean with ease. It comes with 4 quarts capacity and hence great for parties at home. In addition to that, this 4 quart ice cream maker is versatile and can be used for gelato and frozen yoghurt as well. 

Portability and cleaning 

This Nostalgia Blue Ice Cream Maker comes with an easy to carry handle that makes it convenient to move from one place to the other. Cleaning is just a breeze. It is made of plastic material that is easy to wipe clean after use. 

Therefore, if you are looking for a plastic ice cream maker for making ice cream for your family, or partying with friends, this brand can do. 

Motor and compatibility 

Starting with compatibility, Nostalgia Blue Ice Cream Maker works perfectly with all the Nostalgia brand ice cream kits. This makes it easy to achieve different flavors. In addition to that, this ice cream maker comes with a powerful motor and motor lock that makes churning an effortless task.


Compatible with all Nostalgia brand kits

Durable and easy to use

Easy to clean after use

See-through lid for viewing bucket contents when churning

Easy carry handle for convenience when moving around

Powerful electric motor for effortless and efficient churning


The motor is a bit loud when in operation

Expert opinion: This bucket is wholly made of plastic material and with a powerful motor and good capacity. It is recommendable for making ice cream at home or parties since it is portable and you can carry with ease.

[amazon fields=”B07VVDTSQR” button_text=”Buy on Amazon” value=”button”]

Nostalgia Wood Ice Cream Maker

[amazon fields=”B00JZMDMGI” value=”thumb” image_size=”large” image_align=”center” ]

Nostalgia Wood Ice Cream Maker is large in capacity. The 6-quarts capacity makes it good for large families and for partying with friends. As the name puts, this ice cream maker is made of wood that is easy to wipe clean. It also looks classy and modern and useful for making frozen yogurt and gelato apart from ice cream. 

Material construction 

This product is made from real wood and looks classy in its old-fashioned way. The material also makes it a durable bucket that can last long. With the same material, cleaning it is just a wipe and you can do away with mess without strain. 


On performance, Nostalgia Wood Ice Cream Maker is a great product that works perfectly well to produce the best ice cream that you can enjoy. It comes with a powerful motor that is electric and thus no manual churning.


Relatively larger capacity compared to its similar types

Powerful and efficient churning motor

Real wood construction that is easy to clean

Durable and highly portable bucket

Compatible with same brand kits


Dasher design can cause freezing issues

Plastic gears may not last long

Expert opinion: Nostalgia Wood Ice Cream Maker is good for capacity if you are looking for a large ice cream maker. Other features are just on average. It is also wooden and works perfectly for making ice cream and frozen yogurt.

[amazon fields=”B00JZMDMGI” button_text=”Buy on Amazon” value=”button”]

Nostalgia Aqua Ice Cream Maker

[amazon fields=”B07QF6JNL7″ value=”thumb” image_size=”large” image_align=”center” ]

Nostalgia Aqua Ice Cream Maker looks and works differently from the ones above. This one features a candy crusher and a capacity of 2 quarts. It is useful for making ice cream, sorbet, and frozen yogurt. 

Motor and efficiency 

This Nostalgia Aqua Ice Cream Maker comes with a unique durable electric bottom-drive motor making it an efficient and effortless choice for churning purposes. There is no manual effort that you need to make your ice cream with this awesome machine. 

Detachable bucket 

Unlike the rest of the ice cream makers, Nostalgia Aqua Ice Cream Maker features a detachable bucket design that works perfectly to keep your ice cream cold when it is ready for serving.


Opening for adding salt and ice

Comes with a canister and dasher for smooth creamy ice cream

Candy crusher for customizing ice cream

Detachable bucket to keep the ice cream cold for serving

Durable and efficient churning motor


It is a bit hard to load ice

Expert opinion: If you are looking for the best Nostalgia brand that comes with candy crush and detachable bucket, then you have no option but to pick this Nostalgia Aqua Ice Cream Maker. It is efficient but with relatively small capacity.

[amazon fields=”B07QF6JNL7″ button_text=”Buy on Amazon” value=”button”]

 The Competition with Other Brands

There are so many other ice cream maker brands that compete neck to neck with Nostalgia though they may come with different designs and features. We are just going to discuss some few competing brands that include but not limited to the following:

Hamilton Beach 68330N: This brand works just like Nostalgia and with 4-quart capacity. It has all the features that you would need to have for ice cream making. The other thing about competition is on the price point since it comes with a relatively cheaper price compared to most Nostalgia brands. 

Cuisinart ICE-21P1: This is another neck-to-neck competitor that works great for making ice cream and with excellent features and affordable pricing. It is a great competitor that you may not wish away. 

Of course, there are other brands that are worth checking as they compete with Nostalgia electrics ice cream makers in all aspects.

Factors to Consider When Choosing the Best Ice Cream Makers

Choosing the best ice cream makers is not a walk in the park. This is because of the many varieties and competing brands. To make an informed decision, you need to consider on the following features before buying any brand:


What is the capacity of your ice cream maker? This comes in quarts and depending on how big your family is, you can pick the right capacity that you know can be enough to sort your family without having to repeat the process.

Motor and efficiency

You should also check the capacity and performance of the motor to ensure it is efficient. Another thing to check is the motor lock that keeps the motor in its place when churning your ice cream.

Material quality

The type of material, whether it is wood or plastic is something that you need to check. You will get a wooden ice cream maker but lined with plastic from the inside and you should be sure of the type of material that you are choosing for your ice making machine.

Ease of cleaning

Cleaning is another thing to check. You should be able to wipe the mess with ease. Products made from wood and with a plastic lined interior would be easy to clean. This is just a feature that you should always check as a priority.

How to Use Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker?

Using this brand is never a hassle. Each product comes with instructions and directions to help you set up the product before using it. You also need to have your own recipe and flavors that you want to make with your ice maker brand. Just read the instructions attached for each brand type and you are ready to go. It’s simple and doable.


Nostalgia brand is the right choice for use at home due to its convenient design and ease of use. You will find all options with excellent motor and performance, different capacities to suit different needs, and different materials for different tastes and preferences. Therefore, you will not go wrong with this Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Review that comes with options for you to choose from.

Wanna avoid...

- Burning your Ruth's Chris Chicken?
- Too much garlic in your Garlic Butter Shrimp?
- Drying out your Ribeye Roast?